16 In Seed Starting

Choosing Garden Seeds

This is the time of year when your local nursery and garden center, home improvement store and grocery store trots out the garden seeds. Catalogs arrive in the mail selling every type of garden seeds imaginable. What is the different among the different garden seeds advertised? Which is best for your garden?


[Tweet “Grow a great garden from garden seeds this year. Learn how to choose your garden seeds.”]

Choosing Garden Seeds

Many home gardeners start their gardens from seeds. Garden seeds offer many advantages. Not only are they economical (300 seeds for $1.29? Yes, please!), they’re convenient. Root crops such as carrots, beets, turnips and parsnips should only be started from seeds sown directly into the garden soil where you intend to grow your vegetables.

I like to grow most of my vegetables and flowers from garden seeds because of the varieties I can grow. I love to experiment with different tomato varieties, for example, choosing different heirloom and heritage varieties each year to see which ones taste the best and to add variety to my meals. The different tastes, colors, and textures among such common vegetables like tomatoes and fruits like cantaloupes will astonish you when you grow them from seed. Last year, I grew “Vine Peach” cantaloupes in containers on my back deck. I could have lived on cantaloupe during the summer, it was that good! Much better than anything you’d buy in the store, but I never would have discovered the unique, perfume-like qualities of the cantaloupe if I didn’t buy the seeds.

But when you’re starting a new garden, or you’re new to gardening or planting seeds, the different seed companies, packages and products can be absolutely overwhelming. I still feel overwhelmed sometimes as I flip through the pages of my favorite gardening catalogs or stand in front of the displays at Lowe’s or Home Depot. It can be challenging to sort through all the different types of garden seeds.

I’ve put together this simple list so that you can decide for yourself which types of garden seeds to purchase for your garden. I grow all different kinds of seeds, including some conventional, some organic, and some heirloom. You have to find the right mix for your needs, garden and lifestyle.

garden seeds

Types of Garden Seeds

Some gardeners may classify garden seeds differently. The following are the categories I use to identify the types of garden seeds.

  • Conventional: Conventional garden seeds are the least expensive seeds you can buy. The packages won’t say “conventional” on them but will simply be labeled with the type of seeds and growing information. They are easy to find, and perform reliably, germinating well and producing decent fruit, vegetables and flowers. The seeds can be GMO, hybrid, or heirloom. They are simply grown, harvested, collected, packaged and sold without frills.
  • Hybrid: Hybridization has been used for centuries by farmers and gardeners to create new varieties of plants. Hybridization isn’t the same as genetically modified (GMO) plants. Hybridization uses nature’s method of pollination. People select the traits they wish to cultivate in a plant and choose parent plants, acting like the bees by pollinating the flowers themselves to ensure that their genetic selection results in the new seeds and plants. There’s nothing wrong with hybrid plants or seeds, and they often provide important characteristics such as disease resistance to their offspring. New varieties are often created through hybridization, such as taller plants or different colors. Nature can also create new hybrids, too, but mankind tends to speed up the process of hybridization to produce new garden seeds.
  • Heirloom Seeds: The word “heirloom seed” has many definitions, but for most gardeners, heirloom garden seeds refers to seeds from plants that have been under cultivation for more than 50 years. Most heirloom seeds come from non-GMO, open-pollinated sources. These plants have withstood the test of time and produced reliably for decades. I look for heirloom vegetable seeds because I choose to grow my garden using organic methods, and I know that heirlooms were developed during times when pesticides use was infrequent or nonexistent. If a plant could withstand diseases and insects naturally in my great-grandparent’s day, it’s right for my garden. Heirloom vegetable garden seeds often have much greater variety in color, texture and flavor than you can find elsewhere, too.
  • GMO or Genetically Modified Seeds: There’s a great deal of controversy surrounding GMO or genetically modified seeds. I haven’t quite made up my mind about them yet. Scientists say they are safe, but many people are skeptical of them. GMO seeds have new genetic material inserted into the genes of the plants to produce seeds with special characteristics. Corn seeds, for example, have been genetically modified so that they can resist herbicide applications. Farmers growing corn have a lot of trouble in my part of the country with a plant called Johnson Grass. When Johnson Grass grows, it looks just like young corn plants, but it can rapidly overtake a cornfield and use up all the nutrients needed to grow corn. Many farmers use herbicides to eradicate it and other weeds. Corn that’s genetically modified to resist herbicides won’t die but the weeds will. Garden seeds that have been genetically modified should be labeled as such in plant catalogs. If you choose to avoid them, shop for seeds from organic or heirloom seed companies.
  • Open-Pollinated Seeds: This is a new category I’ve recently seen advertised in seed catalogs, so it bears mentioning. Open-pollinated seeds are simply seeds grown under natural conditions, so that the wind, bees or other pollinating insects or processes pollinate the plants the way nature intended. The resulting seeds are simply seeds that are like seeds you might find in the wild. The benefit of such seeds is that the growing and harvesting of such seeds is very easy on the environment.
  • Organic Seeds: Organic seeds must be grown under strict requirements established by the government in order to bear the “Organic” label. The seeds themselves aren’t different from other seeds, but the growing conditions in which they are raised are easier on the environment. Organic farms raising garden seeds do not use pesticides or herbicides, so you can rest easy knowing they haven’t hurt bees or other pollinators as they produced their seeds. The resulting plants from organic seeds are NOT organic plants unless you also incorporate organic gardening practices into your gardening routine.

Sunflower with bee

Garden Seed Sources

You can buy garden seeds just about anywhere, but the following garden seed companies offer a great selection of heirloom, organic, and hybrid seeds. These are affiliate companies for me, so when you make a purchase after clicking the link, I receive a little commission, but it doesn’t affect your price.

Jump Start,CK64050 Germination Station w/UL Listed Heat Mat, Tray, 72-Cell Pack, and 2″ Dome


Super Sprouter Deluxe Propagation Kit w/ 7″ Dome & T5 Light

I hope you will start planning your new garden today.

Happy growing 2016 signature blog

You Might Also Like

  • Maria - Livsnyderhaven.dk
    January 13, 2016 at 10:30 am

    Yes I am planning today. To many seeds, chili and tomato…

    Garden hello from Denmark – Maria

  • How to Clean Seed Starting Trays - Home and Garden Joy
    January 14, 2016 at 11:41 am

    […] Choosing Garden Seeds […]

  • Rachel
    January 15, 2016 at 4:29 pm

    I’m soooo excited to start seed shopping soon! Last year was my first year gardening. I have a major lack of space but was able to have success with my first organic container garden on my porch. 🙂 I’m excited for year 2! Love your blog!

    • Jeanne
      January 18, 2016 at 4:47 pm

      Aw Rachel, thanks for dropping by! A container garden can produce plenty of vegetables and fruit. I grew everything from tomatoes to cantaloupe in a container garden before I moved to Virginia.

  • Blogging Mummy
    January 17, 2016 at 4:04 pm

    We have recently got an allotment and are going to be growing so much of our own things. My son is looking forward to planting his sunflower seeds!! Thank you for linking up with #anythinggoes linky with Blogging Mummy.

    • Jeanne
      January 18, 2016 at 4:46 pm

      How nice of you to stop by! Thanks for leaving a comment. Your son will love growing sunflower seeds. Plant them in a circle and he can have his own natural play “fort” made of sunflowers!

  • How to Read the Back of a Seed Package - Home and Garden Joy
    January 20, 2016 at 12:22 pm

    […] to start garden seeds.  The back of a seed package contains important information to help you grow vegetables and flowers […]

  • Home Matters Linky Party #70 | Newman's Corner
    January 21, 2016 at 10:28 pm

    […] Jeanne gets you garden ready and helps with Choosing Garden Seeds […]

  • Home Matters Linky Party #70 ·
    January 22, 2016 at 12:03 am

    […] Jeanne gets you garden ready and helps with Choosing Garden Seeds […]

  • Home Matters Linky Party #70 - Home and Garden Joy
    January 22, 2016 at 12:04 am

    […] Jeanne gets you garden ready and helps with Choosing Garden Seeds […]

  • Home Matters Linky Party #70 - Tidbits of Experience
    January 22, 2016 at 12:15 pm

    […] …Jeanne gets you garden ready and helps with Choosing Garden Seeds […]

  • Home Matters Linky Party #70 - TigerStrypes Blog
    January 22, 2016 at 1:26 pm

    […] Jeanne gets you garden ready and helps with Choosing Garden Seeds […]

  • Wendy @ Living Almost Naturally
    January 22, 2016 at 2:09 pm

    I love planning for my Garden! I just finished ordering all my seed catalogs! Now I just have to wait for Spring! #HomeMattersParty

  • Audrey
    January 23, 2016 at 1:42 pm

    It is with great joy that I realized I am two months away from my last frost date. Time to start the tomatoes! #HomeMattersParty

  • Jamie
    January 23, 2016 at 7:30 pm

    Great tips!! Here in the mountains of AZ, I don’t get to start planting until about April. It’s great to plan and be ready, though! #HomeMattersParty

  • Can You Use Old Seeds? - Home and Garden Joy
    February 3, 2016 at 3:56 pm

    […] Seeds are so inexpensive that I don’t mind spending a few dollars on replacements. I have lettuce, radish, and pepper seeds that are fine to use this year. I need to purchase tomato, broccoli rabe, cucumber, turnip, beet, and perhaps beans. I have a huge bag of bean seeds left, and I think they will be fine, but I’m on the fence about having at least one spare package ready “just in case” they don’t germinate. […]