• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
Home Garden Joy
  • Home
  • Gardening Basics
    • Month-by-Month Gardening Tips
    • Home Garden Tips
    • Raised Bed Gardens
    • Seed Starting
    • Compost and Fertilizer
    • Tools & Equipment
    • Pests, Weed & Problems
      • Plant Diseases
      • Weeds & Invasive Plants
    • Butterfly Gardens
  • Plants
    • Vegetables
    • Herbs
    • Fruit
    • Flowers
    • House Plants
    • Trees and Shrubs
  • Birds and Wildlife
  • Home & Living
    • Thanksgiving & Christmas
    • Canning and Food Preservation
    • Easy Recipes
  • About
    • Herbalism Classes
    • Books for Christian Herbalists
    • Books by Jeanne Grunert
    • Privacy Policy

New Sweet Potato Pie Recipe

October 18, 2016 by Jeanne

It’s sweet potato season here at Seven Oaks Farm, my small farm here in Virginia. And that means enjoying sweet potatoes in all their glory – including as pie.

sweet potato pie

Sweet potatoes are one of my favorite vegetables to grow in Virginia. The first year I had a garden, I planted them. They seem to flourish in our warm climate and although I always harvest them late in the season, they are quite forgiving. They don’t seem to mind a late harvest and provide me with plenty of sweet potatoes for the pantry.

sweet potatoes

 

This spring, I started sweet potato slips, or small, slender roots saved from last year, in water, and then transplanted the newly rooted slips into the garden. Eight slips were started; six survived. Five of the six survived the transplanting process. The results: approximately 25 pounds of sweet potatoes. I’d say that’s a success.

Right now, my harvest awaits in the garage, but next weekend, I hope to can my sweet potatoes. Canned sweet potatoes can be used to make mashed sweet potatoes or for the filling of a sweet potato pie.

Sweet potato pie tastes much like pumpkin pie. Perhaps it’s the spices, but the color and consistency are similar, too. It lacks the certain ‘zing’ of pumpkin but contains a little less sugar. I like to think I’m getting my vitamin A from my sweet potato pie. Yes, that’s what I tell myself…

This recipes for sweet potato pie comes out slightly firmer and with a taste closer to pumpkin pie. I made it this weekend to use up last year’s canned sweet potatoes; if you have some in your pantry, it’s perfect for pie filling. If you only have fresh sweet potatoes, they must be peeled, cooked, and mashed before using as your pie filling.

Enjoy!

sweet potato pie

The pie is done when the center is set or firm.

Sweet Potato Pie Recipe

For one 9″, deep dish piecrust, you will need:

  • Great Value (Walmart brand) premade, frozen pie crust.
  • 1 quart of canned sweet potatoes (about 2 cups), drained
  • 1/2 cup of sugar
  • 2/3 stick of butter or margarine
  • 1 cup evaporated milk
  • 2 eggs
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 1/2 teaspoon cinnamon
  • 1/8 teaspoon nutmeg
  • 1/4 teaspoon salt

 

Preheat the oven to 400 degrees F. Place one frozen pie shell on a baking sheet. Prick the bottom of the pastry shell with a fork several times. Bake for 10 minutes, then allow to cool while you prepare the pie filling.

In an electric mixer, beat together the sugar and butter or margarine; add evaporated milk, eggs, and vanilla. Mix in the canned sweet potatoes. Keep on medium speed, mixing in cinnamon, nutmeg, and salt. Mix for one to two minutes. Pour into prepared pastry shell. Bake at 400 for 10 minutes, then lower temperature to 350. Bake for 40-50 minutes at 350 or until the center of the pie is firm. We “jiggle” the pie gently; if the middle swooshes or wiggles too much, it isn’t set yet. Let cool, enjoy, and place leftovers in the fridge.

Filed Under: Dessert Recipes

Previous Post: « Best Indoor Plants for Low-Light Spaces
Next Post: The Most Important Fall Gardening Task »

Reader Interactions

Trackbacks

  1. Sweet Potato Fries Recipe - Home Garden Joy says:
    June 18, 2018 at

    […] sweet potatoes in the pantry. I’m sick of baking them, baking them in a casserole, and making pies and soup out of them (although the soup was really good). I decided to try my own hand at making a […]

Footer

A hosta plant in the garden

Growing Beautiful Hosta: A Complete Guide

I never thought I’d be the type who gets into growing hosta, but here I am. I’ve often shared stories about Mr. Hoffman, my childhood gardening mentor who lived next door to us. He had a small hosta garden planted next to our driveway. The bluish tint to the leaves, the tall stalks tubular flowers…

Read More

A bird peeking around a bird feeder on a snowy day.

Gardening for the Birds: How to Attract Pretty Songbirds

Gardening for the birds in the winter means sometimes breaking your own rules. The picture above shows my garden this morning after a lovely eight-inch snowfall last night. The ground was covered with powdery snow, and the poor birds had trouble feeding on grass and weed seeds in the fields. But because I had forgotten…

Read More

A dark red Christmas cactus blooming on a windowsill.

How to Get Your Christmas Cactus to Bloom

If you have a Christmas cactus that stays stubbornly green while everyone else’s plants are covered in flowers, take heart. Learning how to get Christmas cactus to bloom is less about secret tricks and more about understanding what the plant is waiting for. Once you give it the right cues, most healthy plants happily put…

Read More

A Christmas cactus in bloom on a wooden table with a window in the background.

Christmas Cactus Care for a Blooming Success

A Different Kind of Holiday Plant Every fall, garden centers and grocery stores fill with plants covered in magenta, coral, white, and yellow blooms. Among the poinsettias and amaryllis, the holiday cactus stands out for one reason: it doesn’t have to be a seasonal disposable. With a little understanding, one plant can bloom every year…

Read More

  • About
  • Plant a Row for the Hungry
  • Awards
  • Privacy Policy

Let’s Connect!

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Substack
  • YouTube

Copyright © 2026 Home Garden Joy on the Foodie Pro Theme